Jump to content


Reconstructions: Pros, Cons, Why, Impacts


  • Please log in to reply
71 replies to this topic

#61 EricHG31

EricHG31

    Senior Member

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 116 posts

Posted 22 October 2011 - 01:14 AM

It just dawned on me...it's time to celebrate the 12th year of the current Golden Era of ballet! Just think of how many Petipa-era ballets have been reconstructed or 'recovered' in various ways in only the last 12 years. Until about 1999 -- the year of the Mariinsky/Vikharev's Sleeping Beauty and the Bolshoi/Lacotte's Pharaoh's Daughter -- the closest that any of us could get to seeing something similar to what the Romanov court saw while Petipa was alive were Soviet or Royal Ballet reworkings, i.e., ca-1946 ballets.

In, say, 1997 or 1998, did ANY of you ever dream that you would one day be seeing all of the following Petipa Era ballets, let alone having DVDs of some or all of these ballets in your video libraries?


This is a great post--and so true. I can remember as a kid obsessed first with the Tchaikovsky ballets, and then the Petipa ones in general, I never thought we'd see anything close to these reconstructions. It just seemed to not interest any of the companies that had the resources to attempt it. I used to continuously have the Wiley Tchaikovsky's Ballets book out from the library, just trying to imagine from the notation descriptions what the ballets were like. I have to say while there's a lot to celebrate, I am still really disappointed that the Mariinsky reconstructions (particularly Sleeping Beauty--with the exception of Act III and some clips) were never professionally filmed, and I hope the ballet returns to the repertoire and is filmed at some point.

I think in a way, it was time for these extravagant original productions to come back--audiences seem to want to see these kinds of ballets more now than they have for a while--although I naively would have never thought about all of the political issues and concerns these reconstructions would bring up, particularly with people prefering more modern interpretations, though I think I understand the sentiment now (even if from my outside perspective, I can't agree).

It's great to see your list--a number of these ballets (like an attempt at a reconstructed Don Quixtoe), I didn't even know about, although I know the Mariinsky and Bolshoi Don Quixote's seem to be pretty faithful to the early 1900's Gorky revision, and as mentioned, Giselle also seems to exist in a fairly close to the Petipa version.

I am really surprised that we've gotten a non Russian company's recreation of Raymonda, before we've had any similar version of Swan Lake anywhere. But I suppose nearly every company already has a production fo Swan lake in their repertoire--it feels like it must be just a matter of time, though... I'd also love to, obviously see a recreation of Nutcracker but that's obviously more problematic. The original production wasn't a success, and it seems like a lot of the Act I elements in particular aren't very well notated--and some elements like the "Beehive" apotheosis would probably be seen to confuse the family audience that Nutcracker attracts in most countries. Still, I admit I'd be ost curious to see it (back when I was first obsessing about thse ballets, Nutcracker was the one that was the hardest to find information on the original production of). We do have a number of important numbers, more or less--thanks to the 80s Royal Ballet the Snow scene, more or less, and in various other productions the Pas de Deux and trepak. It's a topic for another thread, but for whatever issues people have with Nucracker, I do think that all modern reinterpretations have proven that following the original, perhaps simplistic story ultimately works the best.

As for other ballets--while I would be curious to hear about oddities like the Petipa/Cecchetti Cinderella (does the music even exist, let alone the choreography?), the two that immediately spring to mind, are Glazunov's two one act ballets from 1900--Ruses d'Amour (aka Lady Soubrette) and The Seasons. I have no clue if either was notated--Ruses d'Amour in particular seems obscure, I had to find a random Soviet recording to finally hear it (it's gorgeous, as one would expect from Glazunov music). The Seasons has lived on much longer, but more as a piece of music it seems. I used to always think if these did exist in some way, they'd make a nice night long of three short ballets for the Mariinsky along with The Awakening of Flora.

#62 cubanmiamiboy

cubanmiamiboy

    Diamonds Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 5,214 posts

Posted 22 October 2011 - 06:20 AM

Eric...there's thread somewhere asking for which ballets one would love to be brought back to life, and I remember I mentioned both the Ceccett/Ivanov/Baron Vietinghoff-Scheel/Pashkova/Vsevolozhsky's "Zolushka"-(Cinderella), supervised by Petipa and with the gorgeous set designs of Matvey Shishkov ...
http://en.wikipedia....gnani_-1893.JPG
http://upload.wikime...erson_-1893.JPG
http://en.wikipedia....hishkov1893.JPG

...and the Petipa/Golovin/koreshchenko "The Magic Mirror"-(Snow White, which I believe was the last role created by Petipa for Kschessinskaya...No photos available online).

I always think of this two ballets as the long lost sisters of Sleeping Beauty :)

#63 sandik

sandik

    Rubies Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 4,324 posts

Posted 22 October 2011 - 11:15 AM

If you haven't already seen Helene's report on the recent PNB lec-dem on changes pre and post Petipa, you might want to take a look

here

Doug Fullington did a stellar job of collecting and framing examples of reconstructions from old notation scores of Sleeping Beauty and Swan Lake, and comparing them to contemporary productions of those works. The evening was very illuminating, but my particular favorite was the side-by-side Princess Florine example, with Sarah Ricard Orza and Rachel Foster performing the woman's solo from the Bluebird pas de deux, Orza dancing the original choreography and Foster dancing the Ronald Hynd/English National Ballet staging. The thing that was the most thrilling, as Helene points out, is that both versions are theatrically satisfying, and I think her observation is an important one for the conversation here. The older versions of these foundational works are not only museum pieces, they are legitimate theater.

#64 cubanmiamiboy

cubanmiamiboy

    Diamonds Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 5,214 posts

Posted 24 October 2011 - 07:40 AM

What about getting to see once again the "Kingdom of Laces" apotheosis from the 1886 "Les pilules magiques'.. :clapping:

#65 Natalia

Natalia

    Rubies Circle

  • Foreign Correspondent
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 4,388 posts

Posted 24 October 2011 - 08:06 AM

Eric, Russes d'Amour's notations (and related documents) exist in the Harvard Collection but, alas, not Les Saisons.

Here is a fairly detailed list of the contents of the collection, folder-by-folder:
http://oasis.lib.har...iqueId=hou01987

There is LOTS on Little Humpbacked Horse...the Dream is Alive that we won't have to put-up with only the Schedrin score forever! :)

#66 sergek26

sergek26

    New Member

  • New Member
  • Pip
  • 4 posts

Posted 27 October 2011 - 11:57 PM

If you haven't already seen Helene's report on the recent PNB lec-dem on changes pre and post Petipa, you might want to take a look

here

Doug Fullington did a stellar job of collecting and framing examples of reconstructions from old notation scores of Sleeping Beauty and Swan Lake, and comparing them to contemporary productions of those works. The evening was very illuminating, but my particular favorite was the side-by-side Princess Florine example, with Sarah Ricard Orza and Rachel Foster performing the woman's solo from the Bluebird pas de deux, Orza dancing the original choreography and Foster dancing the Ronald Hynd/English National Ballet staging. The thing that was the most thrilling, as Helene points out, is that both versions are theatrically satisfying, and I think her observation is an important one for the conversation here. The older versions of these foundational works are not only museum pieces, they are legitimate theater.


It is good news that Gorsky's choreography is interesting not only to those who live in Moscow.
I would like to show for comparison my variant of the same Swan Lake male variation composed by Gorsky which is being prepared for future Moscow presentation on Gorky because 2011 marks the 140th anniversary of his birth.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YrYxRlf02tY

I've also animated the exercises from his manual on Stepanov, f.e.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lgTWgkKdjZ0

sergek26

#67 leonid17

leonid17

    Platinum Circle

  • Foreign Correspondent
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,413 posts

Posted 28 October 2011 - 12:08 AM

It is good news that Gorsky's choreography is interesting not only to those who live in Moscow.
I would like to show for comparison my variant of the same Swan Lake male variation composed by Gorsky which is being prepared for future Moscow presentation on Gorky because 2011 marks the 140th anniversary of his birth.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0zsW5dyQtn8

I've also animated the exercises from his manual on Stepanov, f.e.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lgTWgkKdjZ0

sergek26


A warm welcome to ballettalk sergek26.

Thank you for posting these examples. I was most interesting to see your realisations and especially found the Swan Lake variation extremely curious and fascinating.

I was first introduced to. "Two essays on Stepanov Dance Notation" by Alexander Gorsky in a translation made more than thirty years ago by Wiley and published by CORD.

#68 sandik

sandik

    Rubies Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 4,324 posts

Posted 28 October 2011 - 07:52 PM

It is good news that Gorsky's choreography is interesting not only to those who live in Moscow.
I would like to show for comparison my variant of the same Swan Lake male variation composed by Gorsky which is being prepared for future Moscow presentation on Gorky because 2011 marks the 140th anniversary of his birth.


The Swan Lake excerpt certainly has a familiar feel. May I ask what animation software you're using?

#69 EricHG31

EricHG31

    Senior Member

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 116 posts

Posted 28 October 2011 - 08:30 PM

A warm welcome, as well! Those are fascinating to see.

I admit, Gorsky has always fascinated me. Photos from some of his productions (didn't he do a Giselle all in costumes that were naturalistic and made it look almost like Martha Graham?), are amazing. I get why Petipa was so put off by his stuff, but I admit, as huge a Petipa fan as I am, I'd love to be able to see some of his reinterpretations. I gather that a good deal of the Don Quixote productions we see come from Gorsky's revised version, as well as some of the Swan stuff in the Soviet era Swan Lakes? Is there any word on what of his work will be done by the Bolshoi for his anniversary?

#70 EricHG31

EricHG31

    Senior Member

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 116 posts

Posted 28 October 2011 - 08:35 PM

Eric, Russes d'Amour's notations (and related documents) exist in the Harvard Collection but, alas, not Les Saisons.


That's interesting, as I always got the feeling that Saisons was performed more (maybe because the music has become one of Glazunov's more familiar pieces--as it should, the part where Autumn fades away into the apotheosis representing the stars and constellations is absolutely thrilling and ethereal, reminding me in a way of some of Prokofiev's Cinderella). I'd love to see someone try to do something with Russes D'Amour--it's great to know that notation exists. As I said, it might make a nice pairing with Aurora, or a piece for students. The music seems so little known (I believe Balanchine used some of it in some work), but is, as all of Glazunov's ballet music is, gorgeous and very "dansant". The story, from what I gather, sounds amusing, and the pas de deux is sweet with an element of yearning.

#71 Natalia

Natalia

    Rubies Circle

  • Foreign Correspondent
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 4,388 posts

Posted 29 October 2011 - 05:26 AM

Eric, the Vaganova Academy staged a 'Petipa-esque'-looking Les Saisons ca 1974, with then-students Konstantin Zaklinsky and Irina Chistiakova among the leads. It was choreographed by Konstantin Sergeev & utilized the complete Glazunov score. The four winter solos (frost, etc.) were supposedly based on the Petipa originals. The costumes and scenery were very traditional (beautiful). Alas, the existing film is in b&w but may be on YouTube, as it was re-telecast on RTR Planeta a couple of years ago, even to US-based cable users.

#72 sergek26

sergek26

    New Member

  • New Member
  • Pip
  • 4 posts

Posted 29 October 2011 - 09:43 AM

A warm welcome to ballettalk sergek26.

Thank you for posting these examples. I was most interesting to see your realisations and especially found the Swan Lake variation extremely curious and fascinating.

I was first introduced to. "Two essays on Stepanov Dance Notation" by Alexander Gorsky in a translation made more than thirty years ago by Wiley and published by CORD.

Thank you for good words. I understand that it's "work in progress" and hope to improve it.
Did you study "Two essays..." as a dancer or a scholar?

The Swan Lake excerpt certainly has a familiar feel. May I ask what animation software you're using?


DanceForms, clone of LifeForms, by CredoInteractive. It is brilliant dance notator Rhonda Ryman who develops it (this information is also provided on youtube together with both animations).


Photos from some of his productions (didn't he do a Giselle all in costumes that were naturalistic and made it look almost like Martha Graham?), are amazing. I get why Petipa was so put off by his stuff, but I admit, as huge a Petipa fan as I am, I'd love to be able to see some of his reinterpretations. I gather that a good deal of the Don Quixote productions we see come from Gorsky's revised version, as well as some of the Swan stuff in the Soviet era Swan Lakes? Is there any word on what of his work will be done by the Bolshoi for his anniversary?


Oh, yes, it was Gorsky who revised Giselle in pure mime style and you gave me idea to translate the description of this staging made by Vera Karalli. As for Don Quichotte the Bolshoi dancer and teacher Anatoly Kuznetsov wrote in one of his article comparing Gorsky and Petipa that "Now (in 1960s), Don Quichotte is the staging of the whole Moscow company but it was developed on the principles of Gorsky". Some of the Gorsky's ideas on Swan Lake was actually used by choreographers in Soviet era, f.e. jester which is so hated by ballet critics in the West. Gorsky liked to do such things to animate abstract classical compositions by mime and make it more real and playful. Also, Gorsky was the first choreographer ever created symphonic ballet – to Glazounov’s Fifth Symphony in 1916.
The site of Bolshoi was upgraded to the opening of historical stage and old links doesn't work now. Of course, it is pity that none of the works will be revived to 140th Anniversary because Don Quichotte is still in repertory, another titles as Swan Lake, Coppelia and La Fille Mal Gardee made by other choreographers are also in repertory and cannot be substituted and there is delusion shared even by fans of Moscow dance school that a little of his original works was survived. On the other side Bolshoi has restored the memorial table (plaque?) on the building of New Stage, devoted one of the Quichottes performances to Gorsky, re-opened museum exhibition on Gorsky and supported some researches, f.e. new book of Elizabeth Souritz which includes chapters on Gorsky's first stagings in Moscow and presentation on Gorsky on EADH conference in London.


0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users


Help support Ballet Alert! and Ballet Talk for Dancers year round by using this search box for your amazon.com purchases (adblockers may block display):