Jump to content


This site uses cookies. By using this site, you agree to accept cookies, unless you've opted out. (US government web page with instructions to opt out: http://www.usa.gov/optout-instructions.shtml)

Swan LakeRoyal Ballet


  • Please log in to reply
29 replies to this topic

#1 carolm

carolm

    Member

  • Member
  • PipPip
  • 44 posts

Posted 11 May 2005 - 12:56 AM

Did anyone see the performance on Monday, 9 May? It starred Roberta Marquez and Ivan Putrov.

Both of them, as well as Jose Martin, could not complete their jumps or twirls. It seemed as if the Royal Ballet had used very new dancers who were not up to the usual high standard. It was a disappointing evening.

The best part was the Neapolitan Dance with Laura Morera and Jonathan Howells in the third act. But of course Laura Morera is a wonderful dancer.<s>
Carol

#2 ami1436

ami1436

    Bronze Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 325 posts

Posted 11 May 2005 - 02:31 AM

Hi Carol,

I missed the first night of Putrov/Marquez, although I have tickets for it later on in the season. I did hear that Marquez was not as fully on as usual, and I wonder if this is nerves? She does not have the strong turns of Rojo or Nunez, but I still have seen her do impressively well, and she has expressive hands - I'm very much looking forward to her Odile. I'm a bit surprised about Putrov - he has had a hard season with injury, but I heard his Act III turns in the coda (filling in for some missed fouettes) were stellar. Hopefully this was all just a bit of nerves and it will settle by the time I see them.

That said, I think you are new here? Welcome, and hopefully we'll have a lot more Royal Ballet talk to share in the future!

Best,
Ami

#3 carolm

carolm

    Member

  • Member
  • PipPip
  • 44 posts

Posted 11 May 2005 - 03:23 AM

Hi Carol,

I missed the first night of Putrov/Marquez, although I have tickets for it later on in the season.  I did hear that Marquez was not as fully on as usual, and I wonder if this is nerves?  She does not have the strong turns of Rojo or Nunez, but I still have seen her do impressively well, and she has expressive hands - I'm very much looking forward to her Odile.  I'm a bit surprised about Putrov - he has had a hard season with injury, but I heard his Act III turns in the coda (filling in for some missed fouettes) were stellar.  Hopefully this was all just a bit of nerves and it will settle by the time I see them. 

That said, I think you are new here?  Welcome, and hopefully we'll have a lot more Royal Ballet talk to share in the future!

Best,
Ami

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


We saw her a few months ago in Symphony in C and I must admit I was not impressed then. In this ballet she had the annoying habit of taking hugh bows, usually just at the moment that the applause was dying down. I felt irritated and embarrassed on her behalf.<s> Especially when she did not complete the fouettes and instead did a leap!

I, too, was surprised at Putrov. It was those leaps around the stage that was his undoing. I think he was off balance.

We like seeing new dancers so this will not put us off from trying again...not that I do not enjoy seeing the best too.
Carol

#4 Herman Stevens

Herman Stevens

    Bronze Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 294 posts

Posted 11 May 2005 - 03:48 AM

I saw a very satisfying Spectre de la Rose by Putrov and Marquez.

Of course that's not the same as Swan Lake in terms of duress and expression.

However, maybe you caught them on a bad night?

#5 sylvia

sylvia

    Bronze Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 289 posts

Posted 12 May 2005 - 03:07 AM

I didn't think their first night was so bad. I found Roberta Marquez's Odette extremely beautiful. She made lovely use of her arms and upper back, and she was deeply moving - expressive, vulnerable, tragic - I thought her dancing took this right to the back of the auditorium. She was equal to Tamara Rojo in my book, who I didn't think could be surpassed.

What I found even more interesting was her interpretation of Odile. She dances this very differently from all other casts I've seen - sophisticated but not at all overtly sexy. She doesn't try to seduce Siegfried with big smiles or come across as completely evil that I find a bit over-the-top in other dancers. I felt more like she was letting the dancing do the enticing for her. I read in a Swan Lake review last year of a brilliant Odile, who's dancing had hinted at some backstory, of Odile's own imprisonment by Rothbart - it wasn't something I'd noticed myself, but Roberta's interpretation certainly made me think about this. I did wonder if everything was ok - her balances weren't as long as I expected (and she can hold some impressively long ones), her fouettes were done on the right leg and she did cut them short, leaping to the side to fill up the rest of the music and recover at the back of the stage. And the rest of act III I think didn't seem to go so well for her. But otherwise I thought she was wonderful, everything I thought I'd want to see in Swan Lake and she still surprised me.

I like her bows :wink: They're very extravagant, and she's one of only two ballerinas who carefully chooses a flower from her bouquet and presents it to her partner. I'm sure you can tell I'm a fan. I wasn't to start with, when she first guested in Sleeping Beauty, and I was surprised she was joining the RB given how top-heavy the female ranks are. But I love dancers with expressive eyes, and Roberta's just sparkled in everything, particularly her Giselle, and her Fille was by far the best I've seen.

Ivan Putrov isn't one of my favourites in this role but I thought he danced it beautifully as always. Marquez and Putrov make a marvellous, exciting partnership IMO, even though their training comes from opposite sides of the world, and together they have tons of chemistry and charisma. I think her warmth and joyfulness bring out the best in Ivan, and they're a cast I always make a point of seeing. The top ranks are a bit swamped with great dancers and brilliant partnerships at the moment so I think they'd get more attention otherwise.

Monday was Roberta Marquez's Covent Garden debut, but she's danced this with Ivan Putrov before on the Russia tour a couple years ago, and certainly she must have done it many times in Brazil and guesting all over. I'm seeing them again later this month so I'll be curious to see if it's any different.

Having mounted my spirited defence of the evening, just want to take the opportunity to welcome Carol too :toot:

#6 ami1436

ami1436

    Bronze Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 325 posts

Posted 12 May 2005 - 03:33 AM

Thanks, Sylvia, for another report, and yes, Herman Stevens, I loved the Spectre that Ivan did. I feel like he's really growing into his roles, especially in the past few years.

I agree with Sylvia that I think these two make an exciting partnership, and that Marquez has the most expressive eyes. Her balances in Rose Adage are the most impressive *and* artistic I've seen. Even if she's done this before with Ivan, there must be some nerves with a Covent Garden debut...

And nothing wrong with fouettes on the right leg - my right leg is much stronger as well! :wink:

However, I wouldn't call either Putrov or Marquez a 'new' dancer - yes, Marquez is relatively new to the Royal, but at both of their young ages they've had pretty impressive runs so far!

Well, hopefully will have some more reports of the other casts this run, and will be able to watch how this particular cast grows!

#7 sylvia

sylvia

    Bronze Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 289 posts

Posted 12 May 2005 - 03:48 AM

I agree with Sylvia that I think these two make an exciting partnership, and that Marquez has the most expressive eyes.  Her balances in Rose Adage are the most impressive *and* artistic I've seen.  Even if she's done this before with Ivan, there must be some nerves with a Covent Garden debut...

And nothing wrong with fouettes on the right leg - my right leg is much stronger as well!  :wink:

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


It was a surprise I guess, just to see her turning the other way. Isn't that one of the technical challenges of Act III - that most of the steps are done on the left, capped off by fouettes on that dying left leg? But certainly she does things her own way - I agree, in the Rose Adage where she actually substitutes the last promenade in attitude for an extra long balance, did make my eyes bulge!

#8 carolm

carolm

    Member

  • Member
  • PipPip
  • 44 posts

Posted 12 May 2005 - 05:17 AM

I didn't think their first night was so bad. I found Roberta Marquez's Odette extremely beautiful. She made lovely use of her arms and upper back, and she was deeply moving - expressive, vulnerable, tragic - I thought her dancing took this right to the back of the auditorium. She was equal to Tamara Rojo in my book, who I didn't think could be surpassed.

What I found even more interesting was her interpretation of Odile. She dances this very differently from all other casts I've seen - sophisticated but not at all overtly sexy. She doesn't try to seduce Siegfried with big smiles or come across as completely evil that I find a bit over-the-top in other dancers. I felt more like she was letting the dancing do the enticing for her. I read in a Swan Lake review last year of a brilliant Odile, who's dancing had hinted at some backstory, of Odile's own imprisonment by Rothbart - it wasn't something I'd noticed myself, but Roberta's interpretation certainly made me think about this. I did wonder if everything was ok - her balances weren't as long as I expected (and she can hold some impressively long ones), her fouettes were done on the right leg and she did cut them short, leaping to the side to fill up the rest of the music and recover at the back of the stage. And the rest of act III I think didn't seem to go so well for her. But otherwise I thought she was wonderful, everything I thought I'd want to see in Swan Lake and she still surprised me.

I like her bows :wink: They're very extravagant, and she's one of only two ballerinas who carefully chooses a flower from her bouquet and presents it to her partner. I'm sure you can tell I'm a fan. I wasn't to start with, when she first guested in Sleeping Beauty, and I was surprised she was joining the RB given how top-heavy the female ranks are. But I love dancers with expressive eyes, and Roberta's just sparkled in everything, particularly her Giselle, and her Fille was by far the best I've seen.

Ivan Putrov isn't one of my favourites in this role but I thought he danced it beautifully as always. Marquez and Putrov make a marvellous, exciting partnership IMO, even though their training comes from opposite sides of the world, and together they have tons of chemistry and charisma. I think her warmth and joyfulness bring out the best in Ivan, and they're a cast I always make a point of seeing. The top ranks are a bit swamped with great dancers and brilliant partnerships at the moment so I think they'd get more attention otherwise.

Monday was Roberta Marquez's Covent Garden debut, but she's danced this with Ivan Putrov before on the Russia tour a couple years ago, and certainly she must have done it many times in Brazil and guesting all over. I'm seeing them again later this month so I'll be curious to see if it's any different.

Having mounted my spirited defence of the evening, just want to take the opportunity to welcome Carol too :toot:

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Well, we knew that most of the audence did not agree with us as they clapped like mad while we clapped gently. We left the theatre feeling very disappointed. I guess I was disturbed by her bows because I felt she had not danced as well as she bowed.<s>

Did you not think that Laura Morera and Jonathan Howells were excellent in the Neapoplitan Dance?
Carol
Carol

#9 ami1436

ami1436

    Bronze Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 325 posts

Posted 12 May 2005 - 05:33 AM

It was a surprise I guess, just to see her turning the other way. Isn't that one of the technical challenges of Act III - that most of the steps are done on the left, capped off by fouettes on that dying left leg? But certainly she does things her own way - I agree, in the Rose Adage where she actually substitutes the last promenade in attitude for an extra long balance, did make my eyes bulge!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>



Okay, now one of the moderators or other learned people on this board need to step in and correct my little knowledge of Petipa/Ivanov, but my understanding is that most turns in these Grand pdd turn towards the right - so, if a turn onto pique or en dedans, usually on the right leg, and if en dehor pirouettes/fouettes, on the left leg. From the way I've learned the little rep I know (Kitri, Black Swan, Coppelia, Sleeping Beauty, Corsaire.... racking my brain here), this is just 'how it's done', but there is the 'artistic freedom' to slightly change these/do them the other way on the other leg?

However, there are long balances on the right leg in a lot of these - so! Someone who has more knowledge of the choreography?

#10 sylvia

sylvia

    Bronze Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 289 posts

Posted 12 May 2005 - 07:39 AM

Well, we knew that most of the audence did not agree with us as they clapped like mad while we clapped gently.  We left the theatre feeling very disappointed.  I guess I was disturbed by her bows because I felt she had not danced as well as she bowed.<s>

Did you not think that Laura Morera and Jonathan Howells were excellent in the Neapoplitan Dance?
Carol
Carol

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


I suppose if she felt she hadn't danced up to her usual standard, she'd still want to make the impression she had by bowing grandly - if she'd taken her bows in a more humble manner then definitely I'd think something was wrong :wink:

What did you think of Roberta's white acts Carol? I found her very moving, as I said amonst the best I've seen, though the people I spoke to were of mixed opinions, from high praise to a bit disappointed (not that she was bad, but that she wasn't as good as expected).

I think I'm a bit Swan Lake-d out, (even though I haven't seen it since November) I've seen certain dancers in certain National dances, pas de trois, big swan variations, so many times. But I don't tire of seeing Laura Morera and Jonathan Howells in Neapolitan. Howell's is dancing Bottom tonight in first night of The Dream/New Bruce ballet/Rite of Spring Mixed bill, and I'm excited about that too.

#11 sylvia

sylvia

    Bronze Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 289 posts

Posted 12 May 2005 - 07:50 AM

It was a surprise I guess, just to see her turning the other way. Isn't that one of the technical challenges of Act III - that most of the steps are done on the left, capped off by fouettes on that dying left leg? But certainly she does things her own way - I agree, in the Rose Adage where she actually substitutes the last promenade in attitude for an extra long balance, did make my eyes bulge!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>



Okay, now one of the moderators or other learned people on this board need to step in and correct my little knowledge of Petipa/Ivanov, but my understanding is that most turns in these Grand pdd turn towards the right - so, if a turn onto pique or en dedans, usually on the right leg, and if en dehor pirouettes/fouettes, on the left leg. From the way I've learned the little rep I know (Kitri, Black Swan, Coppelia, Sleeping Beauty, Corsaire.... racking my brain here), this is just 'how it's done', but there is the 'artistic freedom' to slightly change these/do them the other way on the other leg?

However, there are long balances on the right leg in a lot of these - so! Someone who has more knowledge of the choreography?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Not Petipa/Ivanov, but I remember at a masterclass recently we were told that Dowell used to turn 'the other way', so there are two versions of The Dream notation, one Dowell version, and one for everyone else!

#12 carolm

carolm

    Member

  • Member
  • PipPip
  • 44 posts

Posted 17 May 2005 - 01:31 AM

What did you think of Roberta's white acts Carol? I found her very moving, as I said amonst the best I've seen, though the people I spoke to were of mixed opinions, from high praise to a bit disappointed (not that she was bad, but that she wasn't as good as expected).

I think I'm a bit Swan Lake-d out, (even though I haven't seen it since November) I've seen certain dancers in certain National dances, pas de trois, big swan variations, so many times. But I don't tire of seeing Laura Morera and Jonathan Howells in Neapolitan. Howell's is dancing Bottom tonight in first night of The Dream/New Bruce ballet/Rite of Spring Mixed bill, and I'm excited about that too.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


We liked her in the second act more than in the other acts that followed. Perhaps it was the failure of the third act that coloured it all. But even when she first appears, she did not come across as a queen should. I mean, she did not dominate the stage.

We are seeing The Dream etc in June. Did you like the programme?
Carol

#13 sylvia

sylvia

    Bronze Circle

  • Senior Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 289 posts

Posted 18 May 2005 - 02:09 AM

We are seeing The Dream etc in June.  Did you like the programme?
Carol

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>


Have seen it twice already, three times if you count the rehearsal :blink: I love the Dream - I've been waiting a year since it was announced last May for it to be revived! I do think Alina has improved tremedously since her debut 4 years ago - less saccharine, and much more spirited. Johan Kobborg danced Oberon perfectly :wink: Jose Martin was a surprise case choice to me as Puck - I've only seen very small dancers in this, but he was excellent, his portrayl was so vivid and mischievious. And Jonathan Howells was lovely as Bottom - he makes the comedy of discovering he's no longer an ass see so natural - it's hard to explain! The quarrelsome foursome were excellent too - couldn't help but notice that they are all RBS trained - Isabelle McMeekan, David Pickering, Joshua Tiufa, and Gillian Revie. The only thing that surprised me this time was the speed of it - some of the dancing wasn't as fast as I remembered. I didn't have fantastic seats I have to admit - I saw Dream for the first time and many more times from the front of the stalls circle and stalls in the last run and remember being absolutely dazzled by the speed of everything, I hardly knew where to look. But this time, watching from the back of the stalls, knwing what to expect, it wasn't as fast as I remembered, but it's probably just me. Just to also mention Edward Watson's debut as Oberon last night, it's been a long time coming - he started covering the role years ago. I've only seen him dance somewhat passive leading roles until now (Romeo, Palemon) so I wondered if he would pull it off, and gosh, he really did. I was so impressed with the authority he brought to the role. A few of his balances were a little wobbly, but overall it was terrific to see those long legs of his whip through the fiendishly difficult solos.

Mixed feelings about the new Christopher Bruce, Three Songs, Two Voices. It's very enjoyable, all danced on flat shoes, and bursts with uncontrollable energy. The dancers blaze on stage in waistcoats, headbands, long loose hair and insanely bright red jackets. I loved picking out individual dancers, the dancing is gorgeous, all swinging hips and almost constant rolling movement, huge wild jumps and clinging to the floor. It almost looks unchoreographed, unrehearsed, like Bruce had shown them a few basic steps (including a few ballroom ones!) and then given them carte blanche to run about and do what they like with them. But when they're all on stage at once, doing their own thing, it comes across as a bit...messy. Maybe it's supposed to illustrate the wildness of Hendrix's music (I confess I don't listen to it at all, but the ballet does make me want to find some cds!) but the corps bits didn't really work for me. But again, if I instead picked out dancers to watch, it was good fun. I was also so pleased that Bruce had picked out some of the dancers in corps who I reckon will make an impact in the RB in the hopefully near future.

Evening ended with Rite of Spring with Mara Galeazzi making her debut as The Chosen One. It's an indescribably amazing work, best from the amphi I reckon.

Sorry, I should have started another thread for this - the post ended up being a lot longer than I intended.

#14 carolm

carolm

    Member

  • Member
  • PipPip
  • 44 posts

Posted 18 May 2005 - 04:51 AM

After your description, I cannot wait for June.<s> I am too lazy to go and look up whom we are seeing in each of the three dances. The last time we saw "Rites" it was with Tomara Rojo and she was perfect.

I like when the music is so familar--as in using popular tunes--so am looking foreward to the Jimmy Hendrix one. Have you seen "Who Cares?" I guess I am expecting something like that--obviously different music etc.

Thank you so much for writing it all out.
Carol

Edited by Ari, 18 May 2005 - 05:23 AM.


#15 Ari

Ari

    Gold Circle

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 887 posts

Posted 18 May 2005 - 05:24 AM

Moderation note: I edited Carol's post to remove Sylvia's, which was quoted in its entirety. In order to reply to a post without quoting the previous one, click the ADD REPLY button, not the "REPLY button.


0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users


Help support Ballet Alert! and Ballet Talk for Dancers year round by using this search box for your amazon.com purchases (adblockers may block display):