Helene, I believe you and I were at the same performance, the Saturday matinee.
Watching A Garden was almost like watching a ballet class, and the women's costumes, black leotards and skirts with pink tights, heighten the effect. The work is, to me, all about showing off the dancers' refined technique. As Helene pointed out, the arms are quite static, and as a result, the audience member watches the feet and legs almost the entire time. The focus is on the so-called "basics" of ballet, not bravura steps; the dancers are not performing the superhuman feats that one might see in, for example, Swan Lake or Don Q. However, in focusing on the "simple," Morris shows the audience just how incredible these "basics" are. One is awed by the unembellished. The plain is not plain at all.
M-Pulse might as well be titled "Lindsi Dec." All the dancers turn in fantastic performances but Dec is absolutely incredible. To use a cliché, you just can't stop watching her. The choreography itself feels fun and intriguing. It's a complete counterpoint to the Morris work in its complexity. Speedy turns seamlessly segue into "How the heck do they do that?" partnering and a constant changing-of-the-guard-- someone always seems to be exiting or entering the stage. Although the different sections feel a little too disparate, I look forward to seeing more of Gaines' work as he further emerges as a choreographer.
3 Movements and M-Pulse are of a similar vein: seamless transitions and endlessly enthralling movement. 3 Movements was my favorite of the program. I'm struggling with describing the movement. Perhaps it was because the M-Pulse's ending tableau was on my mind that all relationships in 3M seemed to be combative. There seemed to be a constant warring undercurrent. Two dancers would seem to be in an angst-ridden relationship with each other, while united together against another couple, and there seemed to be an element of the "battle of the sexes," though it was, for a moment, resolved into what I can only describe as a kick-line-like formation (Not at all as awful as it sounds ) Like Chocomel and Helene, I especially loved Körbes in this ballet. The sentiment's already been expressed, but I'll say it again: How wonderful it is to have her back onstage! Also, as others have noted, Bold really has been getting even better, and you can see it in this ballet. One more thought on 3M: Anybody catch that the costume design was by Isabella Boylston (with PNB's usual Larae Thiege Hascall)? Would that be the same Boylston who dances with ABT?
As far as One Flat Thing, Reproduced, I can't say much that hasn't already been said, except that I like it. Yes, the music is grating, but the movement itself is so very fascinating, as well as the way that the moments of unison emerge from the chaos. It was also great to be able to see it with another cast than last year's, just for the different energy that the group brings to it. (I do however, imagine that each performance must feel different from any other, given the nature of the choreography.) The piece definitely feels the most current and modern of the whole program, though it is the oldest.