Jump to content
This Site Uses Cookies. If You Want to Disable Cookies, Please See Your Browser Documentation. ×

Rosa

Senior Member
  • Posts

    490
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Rosa

  1. Maybe I'm remembering this wrong but in the Kirov version with Mezentseva doesn't she prevent him from making the vow by lowering his hand?

    At the end of Act II she lowers his hand after he's made the vow. Since the mime is not included in the Kirov version, he does not make/attempt the vow at the beginning of the act.

  2. And thats when Nureyev's version of the ballet comes i and makes everything logical. Since no normal guy whould fall for a bird (at least I hope not) :) ..??....He made the story take place in Siegfried's head, as a long day dream.

    The first act is as usual, but instead of going of hunting, Siegfried takes refuges in his own dreams, you know he's been brought up with to many romantic novels....! Odette and Odile are just "metafors" for his own ideals,....I guess???

    and when he betrays the in his mind, he loses his reason......

    thats one way to look at the story, Otherwise I guess you'll just have to go with the guy likes birds.... :P

    Maybe Nureyev made the story logical, yet IMHO he also made it much less tragic. Having Odette and her betrayal just happening in Siegfried's mind caused me not to connect with either character, and left me feeling puzzled instead of sorrowful at the end. :ermm:

  3. I was recently thinking about Siegfried's vow in Swan Lake. Why does he not break the curse in Act II when he swears twice to love Odette, yet it works at the wrong time in Act III? In most productions I've seen on video/DVD, the dancer playing Siegfried just raises his hand in the vow in Act II and Act III (with Rothbart simply demanding that he swear to love Odile forever). In one or two other versions Siegfried specifically mimes in both acts, "I love you/her. I will marry you/her. I swear!" So I guess I am confused why the vow does not work the first time if Siegfried does the same thing at the lake and the ball. :)

    Any thoughts?

  4. :thanks: Thank you everyone for the wonderful reviews! It has helped me feel like I was actually there. *sigh* Also, I'm glad to hear about all the sightings of present and former dancers that were in the audience. :D Thank you again!
  5. I never realized before how different, unique each performance of the the same ballet production can be. Watching the clips of the International Ballet Festival's Swan Lakes the last two days, I've been amazed how each cast has left their own touch on the ballet, no one performance exactly the same; not regarding changes in choreography, per se, but style, little details, reacting to one's partner, etc. It has been especially fascinating comparing the clips of the Black Swan coda and the Act III finale.

  6. Not trying to be tiresome, and respect people's dislike of the director's 'creativity', but it still is the first time I've ever enjoyed Giselle.

    That is wonderful though that this version drew you into the ballet, papeetepatrick. :) Giselle has always been one of my favorites.

    But I'd be glad to hear if there's another good Giselle DVD.

    Alesandra Ferri's Giselle at La Scala (1996) is the production that has always touched me. I own this one VHS, so I don't know how it looks on DVD. The Kirov version starring Galina Mezentseva is also quite good in my opinion.

  7. What a fun thread! I'll play, too.

    White Swan PDD

    Emeralds "walking" PDD

    Rubies PDD

    Giselle Act II PDD

    Cinderella Act III PDD -- Possokhov (The most moving reunion of Cinderella and the Prince I'd ever seen, very tender while also a bit sexy. Zakharova and Filin were beautiful.)

    Theme and Variations PDD -- with Kirkland and Baryshnikov

    Tchaikovsky PDD

    Nutcracker Grand PDD -- Nureyev

    Sleeping Beauty Grand PDD

    Paquita PDD

  8. I just finished Beauty by Robin McKinley, a retelling of Beauty and the Beast. I'd heard lots of good things about it and finally decided I would give it a try. I was not disappointed. McKinley breathed new life into the characters from Beauty to Beast to her sisters. The imagery in the book was wonderful.

    Now I'm on Jane Austen's Persuasion. I've read all her novels except this one.

×
×
  • Create New...