A few weeks (or was it months?) ago, there was a performance by the Royal Ballet School. The students were technically precise and all the alignment and placement that has been discussed in this thread thus far was there. But there was something missing. A spark, a quality, a joy of movement. Though their technique was wonderful, there was so much more to be desired and to be explored by these students.
SAB students may not have the placement of students of the Royal Ballet School, but what they have is a beautiful means of expressing themselves through movement.
Alexandra Ansanelli (trained at SAB from age 10 on) can be a bit of a mess in class, if you've seen her, but when she is onstage there is no way you will be taking your eyes off her. She an absolute revelation in her love and her grace, and I'm sorry, but you won't find that thing in any other kind of company or any other kind of school. Give me that any day over perfect technique.
This year, as we know, SAB is doing no Balanchine whatsoever, getting back to it's so-called roots. There are four students who have been brought up through the school with major roles/leads and I will tell you that you not only will you find a strong technique, devoid of said mannerisms, but you also will see a love of dance that is unparalleled.
I have heard the stories about people having to unlearn SAB habits, but you also have to respect that it's a different technique that stems from the greatest genius ballet has ever experienced, and is not exactly like the classicism that runs much of the rest of the ballet world.
The one problem is that students often misinterpret the technique based on what they have heard is pleasing to the teachers. Students hear, falsely, that SAB only cares about speed at all costs, lack of epaulement is excusable, etc. This is why you'll notice more mannerisms among summer students who don't yet know how things really work at SAB.
The School of American Ballet has the best faculty imaginable, many of whom Balanchine worked with extensively for years, as you all know, so who better to teach the next generation of dancers? People have been spreading rumors about SAB's supposed downfall for years, and yet in recent years we've seen the rise of some truly amazing dancers from the school.
This year students have been offered both corp and apprenticeship contracts with Boston Ballet, Houston Ballet, Carolina Ballet, Joffrey Ballet, Alberta Ballet, Colorado Ballet Oregon Ballet Theatre, Pennsylvania Ballet, and ABT Studio Company, among others. If there was something faulty in the school's teaching, I don't think a wealth of other companies would be accepting so enthusiastically.
I'm beginning to feel quite guilty now for making such a long reply on something that's already off-topic (and just in my first post!), but I just really wanted to share my feelings. I just want you guys to know that once you see this year's workshop, you'll be re-considering, I'm sure of it. ;)
Again, sorry for the length and misplacement of this post. Perhaps I should have made it in the ''SAB Workshop'' thread.