mnacenani

8 hours ago, volcanohunter said:

Yes, the 2017-18 season announcement states explicitly (in Russian) that it is the "transfer of Alexei Ratmansky's production at the National Ballet of Canada (Toronto, 2011)" and includes a couple of quotes from reviews in Canadian papers.

Thank you volcanohunter for pointing this out, hadn't thought of looking it up. Must say it was lucky for me

to bring this subject up - I was waiting for Balshoy booking to open on Aug. 26th to get tix for this production,

thought it would be new choreography specific to Balshoy. I'm not going to spend money on this, would rather

go and see the original at Mariinka sometime. For Balshoy it could make sense to stage the Ratmansky R&J as

opposed to Strapless or something !

13 minutes ago, JMcN said:

 

Will it be the version he created for National Ballet of Canada?

There is no credits info yet on Ratmansky R&J under Balshoy repertory tab. This R&J will be cinecast next January 21st :

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/dance/what-to-see/watch-bolshoi-ballet-preview-ballet-cinema-season-world-premiere/

May very well be the NBC staging but I doubt whether Balshoy would mention that. Will enquire from friends in Moscow.

7 hours ago, Drew said:

I liked what I took to be Ratmansky's allusions to the traditions of the Royal Danish Ballet -- the company on which he set the ballet. But he has choreographed far more successful ballets for sure.

Balshoy has scheduled Romeo&Juliet for 22-26 November which my friend in Moscow says will be the

new staging by Ratmansky ....... awaiting that one with trepidation !  Current Grigarovich version of

R&J is imho a non-starter, has made a hash of the beautiful Lavrovsky original. I definitely belong in

the "if it ain't broke don't fix it" school !

16 minutes ago, Drew said:

However, In New York I saw Kondaurova dance Anna and thought it was one of the greatest dramatic dance performances I had ever scene.  And that made the ballet more than worth it to have seen.

Dear Drew :  I saw Kondaurova for the first time at Mariinsky in July in Preljokaj's Le Parc ..... only reason why I grit my teeth and

didn't join those who walked out. Was very impressed by her performance, must see her in the great Petipa classics sometime

next season (the hall would have emptied quite significantly had there been an interval ) 

Paxita (Paquita) Mariinsky Theater Thu 15 June Teryoshkina-Askerov

Please let me explain before reporting my post for deletion : I did not see the Paquita Grand Pas which

was part of Contrasts at the ROH this week, but I saw the Grand Pas twice in Piter in June. It was presented

as the second part of the Vaganova Academy Graduation Performance on June 14 and the full ballet (?) was

performed by Mariinsky the next evening. I would like to post my take on Paquita in the hope of provoking

our learned members' comments which will gain me more knowledge and insight.

Prior to the said trip I had never seen Paquita live or recorded, and to do my homework watched the DVD of

the 2003 Lacotte POB staging with Letestu-Martinez. However once in Piter my tutor told me that there is no

definitive version of Paquita since everything except the 3rd act Grand Pas was lost, and usually this only was

performed as what were performed as the full ballet anywhere were crude "reconstructions" of the lost first

and second acts. So on the first night I saw the classic Petipa Grand Pas (tweaked a little by Tsiskaridze, cannot

tell you where) performed by the Vaganova Academy graduation class and lower classes, supplemented by a few

former graduates if I understood correctly, starring Eleonora Sevenard.  This was great ..... wonderful classic ballet

as I would like to see time and again. (however, I did not fall in love at first sight with Sevenard, like I did with the

star of the previous graduation class Alyona Kovalyova. Alyona is supposed to dance Odette/Odile at one of the

two Swan Lake matinees next month and I am checking the casting every day, not posted yet, with the full inten-

tion of making a day trip to see her live)

The next evening it was the "full" three-act Paquita, this one "reconstructed" by Mariinsky dancer-cum-choreographer

Yuriy Smekalov. As you could expect, the first two acts had nothing to do with the Lacotte version. If I remember

correctly Smekalov staged "The Bronze Horseman" last year and not everyone was well pleased with that one. In

any case :  imho the first act music and choreography was nothing to write home about, boring. In the second act

the music and dancing got better and I would say it was watchable. On the plus side my beloved Renata Shakirova

appeared as Carducha, the bad scheming girl - I think she is just a great dancer and "personality", my big discovery

of 2015.

Now the third act :  I would say one detects immediately that this is the real thing, and the first two acts were obviously

faked by "pretenders". I could also see this five nights in a row, wonderful classic ballet, music and choreo an all. No

wonder so many companies dance only this part and don't bother with trying to stage a "full" version, that there can be

no such thing is crystal clear. Teryoshkina was wonderful, I didn't quite click with Askerov but he made up for it as Basil

in Don Kixot last week. But between you and me : I somehow liked more the Vaganova presentation of the third act I

saw the night before, cannot give any concrete reason, could it have the edge slightly in terms of sync, symmetry and

separation, could this be possible vs the Mighty Mariinsky ??

Would love to hear from seasoned membership, credits and synopsis for Paquita version I saw :

https://www.mariinsky.ru/en/playbill/playbill/2017/6/15/1_1900

Letter from London ...

Anna Karenina / ROH London / Thu 3 August
Mariinsky Ballet : Vishnyova - Zverev

I had previously seen the Eifman Ballet version a couple of times on Mezzo, music a potpourri of sequences from Chikofsky, am not
sure where the "train approaching" finale was taken from. Thought this had excellent pdd but rather meaningless, movement for move-
ment's sake ensembles.

London is awful in the summer (as is Moscow and Peterburg and so many others) and every time I make a resolution not to travel to Lon-
don ever in the summer, but again broke it and booked to see Diana as AK thinking this may be one of the last few occasions one could
see her on stage. It was after seeing Diana as Juliet with Shklyarov 4 years ago that I fell head over heels for Russian classical ballet.

She is so engrained in my mind as Juliet that I had difficulty accepting her as Giselle or Nikiya or in any role other than Juliet I saw her

dance ....... a case of obsessive compulsive personality disorder ? Anyway it's against this background that I arrived at the ROH last
evening for my first sampling of the Schedrin-Ratmansky AK, just to be able to see Diana.

Ratmansky's AK is short, barely 90 minutes, and when you take into account Schedrin's music it's a relief that it is not any longer. I  do

have a good ear for music but the "circus music" for the "Gipodrom" scene aside cannot remember any melodic sequence whatsoever.

I did know the story of AK and "a story" is discernible from what is presented on the stage - something I attach great importance to. The

choreo of the first scene I thought had too great a similarity to Mayerling to be coincidental. Then on full use is made of modern stage

mechanics and special fx - one cannot help thinking how great works like R&J, Bayaderka and Giselle are which have no need for such

things to prop them up.

What drove the performance last night was Diana :  take Diana away and I probably would have walked out at the interval along with quite

a few other people who did. Diana is a one-off : the grand mistress of mime, her eyes only would be sufficient even if she did not move any

of her facial muscles. But Ratmansky is not Lavrovsky, and Schedrin is no Prokofiev to be able to make full use of Diana's God-given, once-

in-a-millennium talent. Diana and Shklyarov as Romeo and Juliet, with that music which makes one suspect the hand of God at play, and that

choreography, could make a grown man cry ..... how do I know ??  Takes one to know one I suppose .....

Back to Anna Karenina : this needs a great talent like Diana to be effective, Vronsky and Karenin cannot save the performance. Last night

Zverev made an aloof portrayal, maybe as should be, but did not capture me in any way and I could not help thinking how Ovcharenko would

have acted this role. For me, Anna Karenina was the second best role I saw Diana act, after Juliet. This story has, had, the potential to become

a great work like Romeo and Juliet ....... had Prokofiev and Lavrovsky set themselves to the task. My wife is more receptive and tolerant of con-

temporary works than me, and has famously said that I watch contemporary ballet "like a cow watches a passing train" !  But when a friend asked

me last night what her reaction to Anna Karenina was, she said "could see it again sometime if I am invited and have nothing better to do on that

night" .....

http://www.balletinsider.com/en/archive/solo/7693

As I had posted recently, would really like to see her live as Odette/Odile

in September, will be looking up casting info.

On 6/8/2017 at 1:08 PM, MadameP said:

 

Yes, so I understand.  She was offered contracts at both Mariinsky and Bolshoi apparently, but she chose Bolshoi.  

Saw Sevenard live on June 14th as Paquita when Vaganova staged the 3rd act as part of their graduation

show. I thought she was very good but I did not fall in love with her at first sight, if you know what I mean.

Now back to Alyona Kovalyova - it is being said that Alyona will appear as Odette/Odile at one mat or eve

when Balshoy stages "Lebedinoye Ozero" on September 15>17. Dear God - I must go see this one but when

firm casting is posted ticket prices will have gone through the roof on the "open market". If this rumour turns

out to be true Alyona will be my second bullseye in two seasons, the other one was Shakirova. Seems even

65+ newcomers to classical ballet can spot talent ! 

Starting at 7 pm Moscow time =  4 pm GMT

http://www.medici.tv/en/moscowballetcompetition

An article by Vita Khlopova, my Moscow ballet tutor and friend. Vita is a graduate

of the Moscow Ballet Academy and former dancer herself. Currently a quite well

known ballet historian, writer and lecturer.

http://nofixedpoints.com/martha

MACMILLAN ON THE MAKING OF "MAYERLING" : for the benefit of any members

who have not seen this docu but may want to :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0IntawIGac4

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_6AWGGpckwo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m41t5OKA9Y0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWCsL9Q5TrE

Have still to see Alyona live. Will be at Balshoy next week for Legend of Love but

she has not been cast for any performance. Next season hopefully.

Dear Ashton Fan thank you so much for this post - I really appreciate the time and thought you have

devoted to it, and it has been of great interest to me. Yes - I would like to see Osipova in her signature

classic roles rather than McGregor or Wheeldon stuff. I will certainly try to see her as Giselle and Manon,

as Odette/Odile maybe - SL is not my favourite ballet. I would love to see her as Juliet : I am interested in

ballet as drama. And I will not hide the fact that I have been afraid she would slide back in London, not

having to keep up with the likes of Zaharova, Smirnova, Alexandrova or Krysanova. I know my likes

are quite subjective and biased, as I have become quite addicted to Russian classical ballet. It's a diffe-

rent world there.

Re Wheeldon : I have not seen Strapless but had read the reviews - if I remember correctly Ismene Brown

had posted a devastating one. Where I live I watch ballet on Mezzo almost every evening, tried to watch

Alice in Wonderland to educate myself but could only take less than one hour of it, if you will excuse my

saying so.

I wish I had seen a second cast of Mayerling while I was there, like you did, to be able to judge the charac-

terisation of different dancers - I do like studying characterisation.

You did not comment on Mayerling's music : on a scale of ten I give it say two. I believe I have a good ear

for music but cannot remember any tune from the score. Film music, but even that is more tuneful most of

the time. Don't know whether this was also intentional or not.

2 hours ago, Natalia said:

Edward Watson's Prince Rudolf was filmed for DVD during an earlier run, as JMcN may be aware:

 

https://www.amazon.com/Mayerling-Liszt/dp/B003757W0G/ref=sr_1_1?s=movies-tv&ie=UTF8&qid=1493658763&sr=1-1&keywords=Mayerling+ballet

Dear Natalia I just finished watching this performance recorded in October 2009, with Watson-Galeazzi. With the scene cues page

of the booklet in hand to identify who is who ! Sarah Lamb is Larisch and McRae Bratfisch, and incidentally Polunin is one of the

Hungarian officers. My Moscow tutor Vita texted that she had seen Polunin as Rudolf (probably at Stasik last year) and thought

he was excellent in role. Now : drink, drugs, sex, freaking out ...... I do believe Sergey would be excellent in this role and I would

someday love to see Sergey and Natasha in Mayerling.

There is a still earlier RB recording with Mukhamedov-Durante filmed in February 1994 which I will watch next. Larisch is Collier

and Mitzi is Bussell, and on this Adam Cooper is one of the Hungarian officers !  I will put up with this to reach a final conclusion

on the merits of Mayerling, since two ballet people whose opinion I value think Mayerling is a good work but may not reveal its

beauty at first sight .....

12 hours ago, JMcN said:

PS - Do you mean 28th April 2017?

Yes this past Friday eve, the premiere with Osipova debuting in role. As Hanna Weibye posted on Artsdesk there were

10 principals on stage, as star-studded a cast as one will ever get. Now I will post my own take on the work and this

performance, hoping our seasoned membership will ascribe it to "chacun a son gout".

First the work :  I firmly believe "ballet" must be able to tell a story (hopefully a timeless and universal story which can

be readily picked up by anyone on any continent) through dance only, and one would not have to memorise the

synopsis, go to a couple of pre-performance lectures or "insights", and have to watch the performance looking at

the castsheet and synopsis every now and then. Mayerling with its particular, non-universal story and plethora of

characters which do not allow instant identification regarding who-is-who (putting on surtitles identifying who Rudolf

is dancing with whenever he picks up a new partner would be helpful ) is a thousand miles away from this. Does

anyone have to read the synopsis to pick up the story of Giselle, Bayadere, R&J or Don Q ??  Manon in my view is

less confusing, R&J most suitable for ballet but Lavrovsky got there first and Macmillan's is what we call in marketing

parlance a "me too" product, period ! I will overlook the similarity of the ensemble scenes and steps between Mayer-

ling, Manon and R&J  as this could be ascribed to Macmillan's style (Grigarovich has similarities in ensemble scenes).

This was the first time I saw Watson and thought his characterisation was excellent. However, my companion for the

evening (a ballet guru) was telling me about the "evil" character of Rudolf but I saw no evil Rudolf on stage. Watson's

characterisation came across to me as a weak and deluded person who was incapable of sustaining the pressure of

the rank he was born into, rather than someone bent on doing evil. As such, I found his characterisation excellent.

Now, my beloved Natasha : this was my third attempt in 2+ years to see her live. I flew over in Jan 15 to see her as

Kitri and on the night got Tsygankova instead. Last year in Feb I flew in to see her as Giselle and on the night got

Sarah Lamb. This time I caught Natasha all right but I would rather have seen her as Kitri, Giselle or Juliet. I do not

think Vetsera will be one of Osipova's signature roles : after the performance I kept thinking would anything have

changed if Lamb had danced Vetsera and Osipova Larisch ...... I don't think so. When Lamb replaced Osipova last

year as Giselle I discovered that (esp. in the second act) she is excellent technically, but to me she was not "Giselle"

in the first act, the way Osipova becomes the character, so the second act was a "spectacle" rather that the "spiritual"

experience it can be .....  Osipova really shines as Kitri, Giselle, Juliet and even Lise (FMG is not my fav work) but did

she shine as Vetsera ? (re characterisation, for me it is always characterisation first, excellent technique on top would

make it unforgettable). As I said, I do not expect this to be one of her signature roles. The Royal Ballet keep casting

her in silly "contemporary" stuff and are wasting the best years of Natasha's career. Pure commercialism !

So, some members may think I have betrayed my ignorance, poor taste, judgment, in any permutation thereof, but

I signed up to post what I think, and if I were to take a defensive stance it would be a waste of your time and mine.

PS :  forgot to mention the music : imho totally unmemorable, another minus point. Manon is also a "pastiche" but

in my view the music is infinitely better. Ballet music really has to be tuneful and memorable.

Would like to restart Mayerling exchange in view of the Royal Ballet revival

which premiered yesterday with Osipova and Watson. Have posted starter :

http://balletalert.invisionzone.com/index.php?/topic/42518-mayerling-28-september-osipova-watson/

Was there last night and finally was able to see Osipova in a full ballet.

By chance sat at same table with Hanna Weibye of Artsdesk at intervals who

rushed off after the performance to post her review, the only one online so far :

http://www.theartsdesk.com/dance/mayerling-royal-ballet-review-every-ballet-fan-should-see

I reserve my comments (posted further down) This was Osipova's debut in role, full casting :

http://www.roh.org.uk/events/p7865

Telegraph has now posted a review :

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/dance/ballet/convincing-vortex-lust-insanity-mayerling-royal-ballet-covent/

Here's a picture gallery :

https://www.flickr.com/photos/dancetabs/sets/72157683126384545

(+) A notable review by Judith Mackrell in Guardian :

https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2017/may/01/mayerling-review-royal-ballet-royal-opera-house-london

First Possohov work I saw was "Francesca da Rimini" which was part of Zaharova's "Amore" gala

at the Balshoy last May. Must admit I did not know the story, and the program was in Russki only,

but I could sort of make out the story and looked it up once I got back to my hotel. It is my firmly

held belief that "ballet" must have a somewhat universal story which viewers can discern and

relate to - listening to a pre-performance lecture or reading the program notes re what it is about

will not get me involved emotionally. Does even a child have to be told what Giselle, or Bayadere,

or Romeo&Juliet is about ??

This "ballet" I could not relate to, and am glad that I did not spend time and money to go see it live

- and am hesitant about going to see "Nureyev" in July..

However ...... Olga Smirnova ...... was so beautiful, wasn't she ??

Has anyone seen this in cinema or at home ?  Could not make fish or fowl of it,

would appreciate your comments.

("Nureyev" again by the same team coming up in July ....)

Dear MadameP and Buddy "Spasiba Balshoy" for your posts. As I already wrote I am

envious and sad that I could not go to see this year's Festival but at least I can get a

sense of "being there" thanks to you. Wish I could have come this year, as God knows

what the situation will be this time next year in view of current goings-on !

Aaaaaarrgghhh !  Terribly jealous and green with envy . Next year I will certainly put this on

the front burner, hope it will be as good as this year's festival. Dance Open Gala on the 24th will be

my consolation for this year. Best wishes for any and all members currently there.

On 3/13/2017 at 4:03 PM, Deflope said:

It seems they intend for her to partner with Jacopo Tissi, the Italian Vaziev brought over. They've danced together in several galas and he is very tall too. 

You got it right Deflope ! Kovalyova has been cast with Tissi for Saturday's (April 1st) "Diamonds" :

http://www.bolshoi.ru/en/performances/456/roles/#20170401190000

18 hours ago, pherank said:

I'm not crazy about Tsiskaridze's personality, but so far, he's gotten good reviews for his efforts.

 

Here is Tsiskaridze's interview at Prix de Lausanne 2016 - he talks about how he started teaching ballet

(from 19:00 >) if anyone is interested in hearing it :  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYDhzyC8ys0