I've posted the following review in alt.arts.ballet:
Since 1998, the Paris Opera Ballet has organized regularly some "Young
dancers" programs, which feature dancers from the corps de ballet in short
works. The content and style of such programs have varied quite a lot
(sometimes there was a general theme, for example "Homage to Petipa" in
1994); in general, the choreographies and the casts are announced
This time, the program included 8 works, featuring a total of 26
dancers, all of them coryphees or quadrilles (three of them being
"surnumeraires", i.e. quadrilles with a temporary contract- indeed
it is quite rare to see them on stage with interesting roles).
It began with Anton Dolin's version of Perrot's "Pas de quatre" (coached
by Ghislaine Thesmar) danced by Christine Peltzer, Peggy Dursort, Myriam
Ould-Braham and Miho Fujii. It was interesting to see such a rarely staged
romantic work, but it would probably have had more impact with more
experienced dancers. I especially liked Myriam Ould-Braham, a small blonde
19 years old quadrille who entered the company recently, and danced the
"Cerrito" role with lyricism, grace and lightness. Miho Fujii, a
surnumeraire, was quite charming in the Lucile Grahn role. The ensemble
parts were good, except some rather shaky balances by Christine Peltzer
and Miho Fujii.
The second work was a "Pas de trois" from Lacotte's version of "La
Sylphide". That pas de trois wasn't included in the first version of "La
Sylphide", it was added later and came from Taglioni's "L'Ombre", on some
music by Maurer. In general, I don't appreciate much such pas de deux or
pas de trois when they're taken out of their context: it's really hard to
appreciate such works without the rest of the story, with no sets... It
works well with virtuosity pas de deux like that of "Don Quichotte", but
with romantic works much of the atmosphere is lost in general- or it
requires excellent dancers with a strong stage presence. In that pas de
trois, the dancer I appreciated most was Dorothee Gilbert (17), a
quadrille who joined the company last fall: she was excellent in the role
of Effie, very moving and technically very strong. I was far less
impressed with Juliette Gernez (18), a newly promoted coryphee, whose
Sylphide was not especially expressive and quite icy. Julien Meyzindi (22)
was elegant and expressive, and showed great partnering skills.
The following work was the White Swan pas de deux from "Swan Lake"
(Nureyev's production), danced by Aurore Cordellier (17, another
newly promoted coryphee) and Stephane Bullion (21, coryphee).
I'm afraid I was not very impressed with what I saw: the steps were
there, but there was no emotion. (However, I've been told that they
improved quite a lot on the following performances).
The next work was by Nureyev too: it was the balcony scene from "Romeo and
Juliet", danced by Myriam Kamionka (27, coryphee) and Nicolas Paul (22,
coryphee). I've never appreciated much that pas de deux, and those
contrived male variations... Nicolas Paul and Myriam Kamionka both
were quite good, but there was little interaction between them.
The second part of the evening started with a pas de six by the POB
principal Jean-Guillaume Bart, "Le diable a quatre", on a musical
score by Adolphe Adam. That work had been created in 1997 for
the Jeune Ballet de France. It is an abstract pas de six, which looks
like a nice pastiche of romantic style, with many virtuoso variations.
Not a masterpiece in my opinion, but a very pleasant work, joyful and
musical. All the dancers who performed it (Aurelia Bellet, Ninon Raux,
Nathalie Vandard, Severine Westermann, Pascal Aubin and Bruno Bouche)
were excellent, with a heart-warming enthusiasm.
The following work, Petipa's "Carnaval de Venise", was a new work in the
repertory of the company. It was danced by Lise-Marie Jourdain (23,
quadrille) and Jean-Sebastien Colau (23, quadrille), which had won some
medals in Varna and Paris with that pas de deux. Jourdain, a thin blonde,
looked lovely in her white and silver tutu, and their pas de deux was
warmly applaused by the audience (actually a bit too much for my taste- I
find it annoying when people applause in the middle of the variations!)
Such a pas de deux seems more suited to such a gala than the White Swan
one, for example- here there's only virtuosity and joy, and the lack of
context isn't a problem. I wish those dancers had more opportunities to
dance interesting roles; as quadrilles they dance mostly corps de ballet
roles. Colau had been excellent as Rothbart in the previous "Young
dancers" program, and while his long line might seem more suited to
prince roles, I'm more likely to see him in demi-caractere roles.
It was followed by a pas de trois from "Reversibilite" by Michel
Kelemenis. "Reversibilite" was created for the POB in 1999, and
seems unlikely (as many contemporary dance works created in the
last few years for the company) to be danced again in its entirety.
The pas de trois was the second part of the work, set to Ravel's
"Pavane pour une infante defunte" (the first part was on the
"Concerto for the left hand"). I had appreciated that work when
it was premiered, especially in contrast with the hollow new
work by Jose Montalvo which was just before, and it also benefitted
from the great talent of Kader Belarbi, Wilfried Romoli and Elisabeth
Maurin in the main roles. Now, I found that pas de trois a bit
too agressive and acrobatic; nonetheless there were interesting
moments. It was performed with much intensity by Caroline Bance
(23, coryphee), Jean-Philippe Dury (22, quadrille) and Pierre
Retif (23, quadrille). I was especially impressed by the great
stage presence of Retif, and hope to be able to see him again
on stage. And Yves Cassagne's costumes deserve a special mention
(nice short green dress for the girls, and black sleeveless suits
for the men which really made them look very elegant).
The program ended with Jacques Garnier's "Aunis". That work, which seems
to be the only work of Garnier (who died in 1989, aged 47) regularly
performed, had been part of some previous "Young dancers" programs in 1996
and in 1993. I've seen that work quite a lot of times (on video -it has
been filmed with Kader Belarbi, Wilfried Romoli and Jean-Claude Ciappara-,
in Marseille, in Paris...) and still find it as moving, especially thanks
to the beautiful score for two accordions by Maurice Pacher (played on
staged by himself and Gerard Baraton). Aunis is a region of western France
(around La Rochelle), where Jacques Garnier was born, and some of the
music is inspired from traditional music from that region. It was first
created by Garnier himself as a solo in 1979, and then in 1980 as a trio
(also inspired by Garnier's childhood with his two brothers). The steps
are relatively simple, but the structure of the work is quite subtile,
with many games of symmetry and dissymmetry between the three dancers, and
I find it fascinating. It was danced beautifully by Simon Valastro (20,
quadrille), Martin Chaix (20, surnumeraire) and Alexandre Carniato (20, surnumeraire). My only regret is that the audience ruined the end:
it is supposed to be somewhat circular (the music getting slower,
less and less loud, and the dancers returning to their initial position
on the ground) but people started applauding very loudly before the
end of the music and one couldn't really feel the nostalgic atmosphere
of the end.
It was an interesting evening, in spite of a few unfortunate choices.
I regret that some other very young members of the company (Emilie
Cozette, Julie Martel, Adrien Bodet...) were not cast, and hope
that the young dancers of the program will have more opportunities to
shine in the future.
POB Young Dancers program, June 8
No replies to this topic
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users
Help support Ballet Alert! and Ballet Talk for Dancers year round by using this search box for your amazon.com purchases (adblockers may block display):