Jump to content
This Site Uses Cookies. If You Want to Disable Cookies, Please See Your Browser Documentation. ×

Are Ballet Lovers Cat People or Dog People


Recommended Posts

This question applies to both watchers and doers. There are of course many famous cat lovers in ballet. Balanchine is probably the most famous. Back in the late sixties Suzanne Farrell traveled to Belgium to dance with Bejart with I believe 3or 4 cats. What a brave, brave woman!! Are there any famous ballet dog lovers?

I myself have one cat, a bipolar, passive-aggresive neurotic massive ball of fur, whom I love to pieces. Cat or dog for the rest of the Ballet Talkers?

Link to comment

I'm a cat person, for sure. I've had 2 cats in my lifetime - a tough ole boy black cat who died recently aged nearly 20, and my current rescue cat who's a tiny tabby. She's 10 years old but she looks like a kitten and she always has a cold.

This is a small sample size, but I'm willing to bet that most of us prefer cats to dogs... There are lots of nice cats in ballets (I can't think of any apart from Puss in Boots, but go with me please!) but I can't think of any graceful dogs.

Link to comment

ALthough I do have a (very disagreeable) cat, I'm a dog person. And I think dogs exhibit many of the traits of dancers -- loyalty, persistence, work ethic, and ability to enduring pain and suffering. Also, dogs are very emotional, with very expressive faces, which I think is often the hallmark of a great dancer.

Link to comment

Our household is made kinder, wiser, and more graceful by the presence of one dog :) , one cat. :)

As to ballets, there's Andree Howard's "Lady into Fox," but to my knowledge there is no "Lady into Fox Hound."

Robbins' "The Small House of Uncle Thomas," for King and I, has blood hounds.

Northern Ballet Theater has a version of "Peter Pan" which includes a dancer role for the dog, Nana. Link: http://www.northernballettheatre.co.uk/peterpan.html

Link to comment

Jerry Robbins was a dog lover. My dog, Loretta, was one beneficiary of a Robbins display of unbridled affection. The previous evening, Robbins had been a Jeopardy clue, but I knew better than to intrude on his moment with bliss with the four-legger to let him know. Loretta's Central Park playgroup included dogs who dragged their ABT humans along, inclulding V.Barbee and L. Ketterndahl, D. Radojevic, A. McKerrow and J. Gardner.

Baryshnikov has had dogs, but I don't know about cats. In Elusive Muse, we see Suzanne walking her two dogs. Peter and Darci have had dogs. Christine Redpath was often seen walking a golden retriever. Kipling Houston had a beautiful Malamute. I used to see Samantha Allen walking a doggie. Katey Tracey has a little ball of black fur. DanceMagazine's recent piece on Gelsey showed her in the company of canines. That's just off the top of my head.

I thoroughly agree with canbelto's comparison of dogs to dancers. They work like dogs in order to look like cats! :)

Link to comment
I thoroughly agree with canbelto's comparison of dogs to dancers. They work like dogs in order to look like cats! :)

What a great assessment! So true! I also think that there are 'dog' dancers and then there are 'cat' dancers. The dog dancers hold nothing back. They are always dancing 200%. They are an emotional tour-de-force. They often push the limits of good taste and form. Critics call them less graceful, perhaps more vulgar, undisciplined. Their fans love their heart-on-sleeves style. Dog dancers: Maya Plisetskaya, Rudolf Nureyev, Lynn Seymour, Irek Mukhamedov, Carlos Acosta, Diana Vishneva.

Then there are the cat dancers. They are a bit aloof and mischevious, and dance with a graceful perfection that is awe-inspiring. Cat dancers: Irina Kolpakova, Mikhail Baryshnikov, Suzanne Farrell, Svetlana Zakharova, Manuel Legris.

To get back on topic, I've seen Marie-Agnes Gillot photographed with her two dachsunds.

Link to comment
Also, dogs are very emotional, with very expressive faces, which I think is often the hallmark of a great dancer
Preferably without letting their tongues hang out. :)
The dog dancers hold nothing back. They are always dancing 200%. They are an emotional tour-de-force. They often push the limits of good taste and form. Critics call them less graceful, perhaps more vulgar, undisciplined. Their fans love their heart-on-sleeves style. [....]

Then there are the cat dancers. They are a bit aloof and mischevious, and dance with a graceful perfection that is awe-inspiring.

I love these categories. :) And your examples are right-on. They fit quite well with Robert Greskovic's distinction between Apollonians (cat) and Dionysians (dog).

I know the typology of dog-dancer and cat-dancer will be with me when the perfomance season begins in this area and I can start looking at live dancers on stage. Thanks, canbelto.

Link to comment
What a great assessment! So true! I also think that there are 'dog' dancers and then there are 'cat' dancers. The dog dancers hold nothing back. They are always dancing 200%. They are an emotional tour-de-force. They often push the limits of good taste and form. Critics call them less graceful, perhaps more vulgar, undisciplined. Their fans love their heart-on-sleeves style. Dog dancers: Maya Plisetskaya, Rudolf Nureyev, Lynn Seymour, Irek Mukhamedov, Carlos Acosta, Diana Vishneva.

Then there are the cat dancers. They are a bit aloof and mischevious, and dance with a graceful perfection that is awe-inspiring. Cat dancers: Irina Kolpakova, Mikhail Baryshnikov, Suzanne Farrell, Svetlana Zakharova, Manuel Legris.

Ooohh Canbelto! I love your dancer distinctions! :)

Allegra Kent, very much a cat dancer.

Link to comment

Watching that Sleeping Beauty film, it occurred to me that Alla Sizova and Yuri Soloviev were like golden retrievers. Blonde, beautiful, sunny, radiating warmth, and extremely athletic.

Wendy Whelan: very much a cat dancer. Long, sinewy, with a stony inscrutable face. Watch her twist and turn and marvel.

Link to comment
Dog dancers: Maya Plisetskaya, Rudolf Nureyev, Lynn Seymour, Irek Mukhamedov, Carlos Acosta, Diana Vishneva.

Right on with Diana Vishneva, and I've seen her with a mid-sized white dog. Yet, just as Farrell Fan pointed out, cat dancer Suzanne (actually I think Farrell is both, and more; well, everything) can like dogs, and Diana's favorite partner is cat-like Vladimir Malakhov.

Link to comment
Watching that Sleeping Beauty film, it occurred to me that Alla Sizova and Yuri Soloviev were like golden retrievers. Blonde, beautiful, sunny, radiating warmth, and extremely athletic.

I like the thoughts, but could never see Alla Sizova as anything but the most beautiful cat in the Sleeping Beauty film--not the aloof sort of cat,though;rather one who could live with a lovely big poodle or maybe, as here, M. Soloviev, who is more akin to your golden retriever to me. But I'm a cat person, thinking they are the most beautiful things in the world, if not always the nicest. Mlle. Sizova is perhaps the prettiest ballerina I've ever laid eyes on, quite apart from the beauty of her dancing--I mean I can easily see her in spring collections at Givenchy or something--and so I have no choice but to see that delicate smile as catlike. She is just a bloody knockout.

I find Nureyev as well as much more catlike than doglike, and this has to do with the sly movement that he can do even though he's got that generous look, too. Anyway, not that much like either one, more horselike.

Makarova very catlike of the tough-charmer sort that would win prizes at Madison Square Garden Cat Show. McBride also very catlike of the sweetest sort of feline.

Link to comment
I find Nureyev as well as much more catlike than doglike, and this has to do with the sly movement that he can do even though he's got that generous look, too. Anyway, not that much like either one, more horselike.

Nureyev was a panther. Also, dogs are pack animals, and RN was never a member of any pack, not even back home.

Although Fonteyn also owned dogs from time to time, she was a Cat Woman, in more senses than one, like Vivien Leigh -- both collected cat figurines.

Speaking for myself, I like dogs just fine, except they require a great deal of attention and entertaining and although some can be left alone it is still not good for them, and I can't commit to that much time. I have two kitties, a skittish but sweet calico cat and a little gray tabby who is the mistress of all she surveys and has the local dogs terrified.

Link to comment

as a 'dog person' i was amused to read a passage in kavanagh's ashton biog - SECRET MUSES - that recounts how ashton felt, as a non-cat person, that he was continually surrounded by people - ballet people - who ADORED cats, and how as a consequence he felt oppressed and outnumberd on that account.

i read it aloud w/ relish on the phone as soon as came across to a huge 'cat person' i know, and who also adores ashton, and she noted how it was just like me to pick that passage out and read it to her.

we had a good laugh. she still adores cats (w/ no comment from me).

Link to comment

Nureyev in the last years of his life had a Rottweiler named Soloria. It was originally Solor, but then Nureyev found out that he was a she, so she became Soloria. Of course this was in tribute to Nureyev's favorite ballet and the reconstruction that he had been so feverishly preparing of La Bayadere.

And even though Fonteyn called him a "young lion" I stand by my conviction that Nureyev was the ultimate "dog" dancer. His tongue even hung out sometimes. :)

And to take this metaphor further, let's take a look:

My cat

Irina Dvorovenko, a cat dancer

Suzanne Farrell, a cat dancer

My dog

Diana Vishneva, a dog dancer

Rudolf Nureyev, dog dancer

Link to comment

I like some dogs very much, but I see from this discussion that, although not all ballet dancers remind me of cats, I haven't ever thought even one reminded me of a dog--some other animals besides cats, but never dogs. What dancers own as pets is a celeb sort of thing, probably would interest me only if one owned something really exotic like a serval or terrible snake.

Link to comment

I'm a cat person married to a cat person. Our longest living cat, Natasha (no prizes for guessing after whom she was named) lived until her 23rd birthday.

I have learned to purr, growl & hiss. This comes in handy from time to time.

But there have been doggies who have won my heart, including Carbro's lovely, lollopng, lovable & looney Loretta. One of a kind.

Darci had a cat and a mynah bird prior to Peter.

I don't see Acosta as a dog type dancer at all. Stalking, prancing, darting, leaping .. especially leaping. He is usually described as pantherine & I must agree.

Link to comment
But there have been doggies who have won my heart, including Carbro's lovely, lollopng, lovable & looney Loretta. One of a kind.
Thank you so much, zerbinetta! Such a sweet, accurate (if I may say) and alliterative depiction .

Loretta was a dog, but she was as much a cat person as anyone I know. She memorized all the windows and storefronts where she'd ever seen a cat, and several times a week made the rounds of them -- the 70-minute (on a good day) kitty tour. Never showed much interest in ballet, though.

Link to comment

Balanchine on Farrell, the "cat dancer":

She has speed, alertness, understanding. Her muscles are flexible. She responds beautifully. It is like the cat family. There are lions and tigers, pumas and leopards, and they are all difdferent. Why? It is the body's chemistry. Suzanne is a cheetah, the fastest. Others are lions, slow and lumbering. Yes, Suzanne is a cheetah."
I guess you might also include the famous off-centeredness and risk-taking as "cat-like" too. Plus the efficient and often disguised preparations for jumps and turns.

And cats always end up on the feet.

Link to comment

I'm definitely a cat person (always a bit too like to lose much time trying to pet any cat I see in the street, unfortunately they generally stare at me and then run away frightened...), the proud owner (I'd better say "servant") of a small black and white cat called Venise (and my parents had three cat, a male tabby called Fripounet who unfortunately ran away when he was only 1 year old, and later successively two cats who were wandering in the neighborhood, good old female yellow-bellied tabby Marcel and later hot tempered female calico Mimile- yes they were female but with male names, go figure...) My husband is more of a dog person and loves basset hounds, but such dogs require more room and exercise that what we could offer now, so he just collects basset hound related items- and now that he has Venise he has become almost as crazy about cats as myself.

That's not really ballet, but Venise's jumping accomplishments can be admired there:

http://www.bruhat.net/jumping-venise.mpg

To get back on topic, I've seen Marie-Agnes Gillot photographed with her two dachsunds.

Yes indeed, I remember seeing her with them at the POB's "entrée des artistes". I remember some other dancers had small dogs, one of them travelled in a bag on its owner's motorbike but I can't remember which dancers...

In Mannoni's "Les étoiles de l'Opéra de Paris" published in the early 1990s, there are two beautiful photos of Noëlla Pontois with a little dog (I don't know which kind of dog, but it seems to be small, gey and hairy- and it's called "Snouf") by Marc Badran, she looks so joyful and elegant on those photographs... Patrick Dupond mentioned in an interview that his two small dogs helped him when he had to recover from a car accident a few years ago.

And Sylvie Guillem recently mentioned on her own web site that she had a cat.

Link to comment
Venise's jumping accomplishments can be admired there:

http://www.bruhat.net/jumping-venise.mpg

It looks to me as if Estelle is using what in the US is called a "Cat Dancer," and Venise certainly is a Cat Dancer!

I am a cat person, with two in my present, many, many in my past, and I don't know about the future. I also just loved Canbelto's little orange cat.

Peter and Darci have four dogs at the moment, or else Darci was moonlighting as a dog walker on Broadway one evening last season. Many other NYCB dancers have had pups: Pascal had a sweet little beagle named Heidi, the late Wolfe Buchner, who managed the gift shop had a little black and white cocker spaniel named "Oreo," Peter Stark had a terrier just like Toto, and her name was Marilyn. I think that once Peter and Susan Hendl started bringing their retrievers backstage, the floodgates opened. I hope not literally.

In terms of Cats in ballets, most recently at NYCB, Wendy's role in "Musagete," was said to be Mourka. (Sorry but the choreographer's name just slipped.)

Link to comment
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...