flipsy

Frances Ha

8 posts in this topic

Frances is a dancer, a dancer and a choreographer, six or seven years out of the Vassar College dance department, living in New York and trying to make it in the modern dance scene. She’s an apprentice with a modern dance company, and both she and the company are strapped for cash. But she doesn’t even want to think about giving up her dream.

Frances shares her dreams with her roommate, a brainy classmate who’s trying to make it on the literary scene. Together they are going to sweep the world off its feet, they’ll have an apartment in Paris, they’ll collect lovers and dozens of honorary degrees. But when roommate Sophie finds a rich new boyfriend, her life changes and she moves out, leaving Frances alone in an apartment she can’t afford. Frances moves in with a couple of guys, promising to raise her share of the rent once the company starts its Christmas show. But then she gets cut from the Christmas show. Thus begins her painful slide through increasing layers of desperation, toward realizing who she really is.

Who she really is is a beautiful, compassionate, deeply intelligent and funny person who really does have a talent for choreography, but who isn’t going to be famous or rich in this world. Frances coming to terms with this world is the simple plot of this complex character study.

Noah Baumbach is the director and Greta Gerwig is his co-writer, muse and star in this deceptively modest black-and-white flick. It’s a sometimes harrowing look at upper-middle-class college graduates looking for work, love, sex, home, and artistic fulfillment in New York. Most of the dance scenes are shot at a real Manhattan studio, with a narrow hallway strewn with the stretching bodies of twenty-something dance hopefuls. The company director is played by a real dancer, Charlotte D’Amboise, who has the look of someone toughened by years of showbiz, but who retains an eye and a heart for a person of real quality like Frances.

I won’t spoil the ending with a description, but let’s just say Frances is finding her little niche in New York. Frances Ha is not her full name, but it’s partway there.

Share this post


Link to post

Hello, flipsy, and thank you for starting the topic. Baumbach's work has been hit-and-miss for me since "Kicking and Screaming," but Frances Ha sounds like it might be a good one and the reviews I've seen have been very favorable.

Share this post


Link to post

I did eventually catch this on DVD, thanks to flipsy's recommendation. The plot is indeed simple, maybe a little too simple even for ninety minutes. Has anyone else seen it?

Share this post


Link to post

It's on my to-watch list -- dancer friends have had very mixed responses to it, so I haven't rushed to watch, but I'm getting there.

Share this post


Link to post

Loved Lola Versus, this not so much. But did like that she was/is a dancer!

Share this post


Link to post

I must say it is evident early on that Frances has no future as a dancer.....

Share this post


Link to post

I just watched it and was quite moved. There are so many many people like her who have to come to terms with not being the kind of artist they dream to be. But so few movies about them especially with a realistic and happy ending.

I thought Charlotte d'A was wonderful in it.

Share this post


Link to post

What macnellie said. My thoughts and feelings, exactly.

It's quite a contrast to a newer movie about a struggling artist in New York, the Coen brothers' "Inside Llewyn Davis." But then their movies never have happy endings.

I wrote a review which you can read here

Share this post


Link to post