There are a number of references to Hightower in Edwin Denby's
Looking at the Dance, a compendium of reviews and essays from the 1940s. These essays can also bae found in his
Dance Writings.. A quick check of the index shows brief references may give you a sense of her qualities and her rep with Ballet Theater.
Hightower was in her early twenties at the time of these performances. Other young ballerinas at Ballet Theater during the war years included Alicia Alonso, Ruthanna Boris, Nora Kaye, May Ellen Moylan and Maria Tallchief, all praised by Denby. Markova ("the queen ballerina") and Toumanova (possibly her "successor") were Ballet Theater's biggest female stars..
In 1943 Hightower danced in Antony Tudor's Dim Luster (Ballet Theater, Met Opera House), with Tudor, Kaye, and Hugh Laing.
Nov. 1943: Danced in the Nutcracker Pas de Deux (Ballet Theater) with Andrew Eglevsky, a performance of "exceptional brilliance and classic finish."
Quote
This time her poses were completely plastic and her timing of the dance phrases was sure. She gave the sense of finishing one phrase before the next: of fulfilling one impulse and completing it before the next impulse alters the figure of the dance. It is astonishing how rarely dancers are able to have so clear a control; a control which Miss Markova, of course, possesses to a remarkable degree.
Because of Miss Hightower's technical brilliance, her naturally forthright manner of dancing was more than ever attractdive. And Eglevsky, her partner, was at his very best, too; not only technically superb and magnificently simple, but with that large open-heartedness that he alone brings to classic dancing. His warm and loyal manner toward Miss Hightower added a great deal to the freshness the whole dance had; and in her spontaneous delight, Miss Hightower looked really radiant. It was a great pleasure to see her in this final triumph at the close of a season in which she has been so remarkable.
The Hightower/Eglevsky Nutcracker was their signature pdd at this time. To give you an idea of BT's repertoire at that time, Jerome Robbins danced the role of Petrouchka that same evening.
1944: Danced the role of Papillon in Fokine's Carnaval (Ballet Theater). Denby descrdibed her as "impetuous."
May 1944: The "white" acts of Swan Lake.
Quote
Rosella Hightower, blossoming into New York's favorite among the younger classical dancers, gave a quite exceptionally fine performance as the Swan Queen in Swan Lake at Ballet Theater's Saturday matinee at the Metropolitan.
October 1944: Danced Myrtha to Tamara Toumanova's Giselle and Anton Dolin's Albrecht. Denby praises were "magnificent leaps, beautiful arm gestures" and says that she was "at her best." The same month Denbyi criticized Ballet Theater, "our strongest dance company," as follows: "As a company it still needs more of the physical sincerity, the warmheartedness that it admires readily and generously when it sees its own home-grown ballerina, Rosella Hightower, dancing."
[Dimitri Romanoff was the Prince; John Kriza was Benno.]
Miss Higihtower was superb in the great adagio, better than she has ever been in it efore. Her phrasing was sustained, classical and lucid. All through the piece her slow gestures had a beautiful repose. The quicker ones, at which she usually excels, seemed to hasty by contrast. But in her second allegro solo she was again very brilliant indeed. It is a great pleasure to watch her growing into a complete ballerina.
Other roles:
-- one of the trio of bathers in Massine's Aleko;
-- "a very funny hoyden" in Lichine's Graduation Ball;
-- the Lucille Grahn role in Pas de Quatre (with Alonso as Grisi, Janet Reed as Cerrito, and Markova as Taglioni.) -- "Miss Hightower impersonates a majestic Grahn";
-- The Street Dancer (Nijinska's role) in Petrouchka
-- Les Sylphides: "Miss Hightower ... excelled in Sylphides, particularly in the two ensemble numbers. While Miss Alonso keeps the gestures of her limbs academically depending on the torso, Miss Hightower has a fine flinging abandon; it is difficult for her to phrase so much energy with delicacy, but one loves the spontaneous warmth of it." (Given Denby's description of Hightower's performance, I was amused to see that Fancy Free was also on that bill, October 10, 1944).