de facto segregated roles
Posted 23 July 2001 - 11:11 AM
Especially at NYCB, have certain roles (read Arthur Mitchell's former parts) become "the black guy part"? Is the racial identity of the dancer an important dynamic in casting these roles? What think?
Posted 23 July 2001 - 12:09 PM
It's a good question, though. There have been "black roles" in certain companies, and I've never been sure whether the roles are seen as racially specific and so dancers are recruited for them, or a black dancer is hired and seems to be placed in those roles. There is one school of thought that the "Agon" pas de deux was meant to be black-and-white. Yet other Arthur Mitchell roles -- Puck, for example -- were certainly not racially specific.
"Othello" is one that has certainly aroused controversy. I remember the Joffrey Ballet, when Christian Holder was a star, cast him as The Moor in "The Moor's Pavane" and the Blackamoor in Petrushka as a way around the blackface problem. When DTH did Smuin's "Song for Dead Warriors," they did the police in white face (no one objected, at least audibly).
Posted 23 July 2001 - 04:33 PM
Posted 23 July 2001 - 06:05 PM
Posted 24 July 2001 - 06:25 PM
him in, was Carabose in Sleeping Beauty and
Tybalt in Romeo. Now these are "character roles" that older dancers would normally do. But, Desmond who was in some of his prime years, was not used correctly to me. I know that he is not of as a classical ballet dancer primarily. But, coming from a company
like Ailey, he should have been given a chance to perform in more classical roles. A great dancer, not at all testing his potential. I don't pretend to know the whole
story. But, Mel, your question, and looking at this subject while thinking about Desmond
got me writing. It has bothered me for a few years.
Posted 24 July 2001 - 08:43 PM
Posted 24 July 2001 - 09:10 PM
Posted 24 July 2001 - 11:05 PM
the ones at DTH, Lauren Anderson, a Priniple
Dancer in the Deep South of Houston, Carlos Acosta, it just seems to me that ballet companies ,at least in the NE US,are resistent to allowing ballet dancers of color
the chance to star in the Swan Lakes, the Giselles and other established and revered parts that are part of the barometer you use to evaulate a career in ballet. You figure
that they would at the very least try to tap
a set of demographic populations, that might
go to a perf., and realize they might want to go and see some more ballet and dance.
Posted 24 July 2001 - 11:19 PM
I think the notion of color-specific roles is unsettling (I'm not saying it doesn't exist). A dancer of any color should be cast in the roles for which his/her talents are suited. Suited can include technique, dramatic ability, and suitability to the role in more intangible ways; someone who is stiff as a performer isn't suited to a jazzy role, or a poetic/lyrical role, for example. In classical ballet, body type -- length of leg and neck, arch of foot, line, body proportions, etc. -- are important; they define roles.
But I'd resist the notion that only a black dancer could dance the man's part in the "Agon" pas de deux (should it ever come to that) as much as that no black man should ever dance Albrecht. Ronald Perry was a very fine Albrecht, in my eyes; very dark-skinned, but with a beautiful classical body and every technical and dramatic quality necessary to make a believable Albrecht.
I also think that the racial issue in American ballet isn't going to be solved at the professional level until it is solved at the school level. There aren't enough black Americans studying ballet to produce a talent pool large enough from which to choose.
Posted 25 July 2001 - 01:22 AM
Posted 25 July 2001 - 07:02 AM
Posted 25 July 2001 - 10:11 AM
I'd also say that money isn't just an issue for middle-class black parents. I know white parents who've forbidden very promising children from going into a company at 18, insisting on college "so they'll be prepared for something, and then they can do what they want." (It's not new, either. Eddie Villella springs to mind.) I think that money, much more than the stereotypes associated in the public's mind with male dancers, is the reason there's a perennial shortage of men. When the Royal Danish Ballet had a strong male contingent they were well paid, compared to the rest of that society, and the retirement age was 50, after which they got a high pension. Most importantly, after they'd been in the company for five years they couldn't be fired. That time was enough to weed out dead wood; after that, a dancer had to be given time to recover from an injury and couldn't be cut at a director's whim. If our dancers could expect to make a high, steady income it would be seen as a serious career, not just something young women can do until they get married (from the mouth of my physician, who pulled his daughter out of ballet school when he learned that "the most she'll ever earn is $35,000; this, 15 years ago), and men of all races will be attracted to ballet as a profession.
Posted 25 July 2001 - 11:00 AM
By the way, can you tell me if it is usual for the stager from the Balanchine trust to join the cast for a curtain call ? I hadn't noticed this practice before.
Posted 25 July 2001 - 11:14 AM
Good to see you on Ballet Alert!
Agon was originally staged at the Royal Ballet by Patricia Neary in the mid-70's. Did she return to refresh it? I think that might have been possible, she has worked with the Royal Ballet several times on settings.
In this situation, I've talked to or read several accounts which state explicitly that Balanchine was fascinated sculpturally by the interracial partnership. Someone like Neary might have heard him say as much.
In other cases, because Balanchine wasn't much for explicating the philosophy behind what he was doing, I think the setters, especially those who worked with Balanchine during his lifetime, tend often to imitate his actions because they have little other evidence to go on.
I've actually seen a few instances where the person responsible for the staging of a ballet gets a bow, not merely with the Trust or Balanchine involved.
Posted 25 July 2001 - 02:05 PM
rigorisly in ballet. All I am saying is that
when you allow such a talent into a co., you can see in a REP. EVE. if he could do it.I think he can do a lead row in a classical ballet. Ballet dancers and companies crossover to take on modern works all the time. Why is it
assumed, that it can't be the other way.
With Anderson& Acosta, yes they are the exceptions. That I can see. But, even there,
they are thought of as Black Ballet Dancers
[ 07-25-2001: Message edited by: campvaldes ]
[ 07-25-2001: Message edited by: campvaldes ]
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users
Help support Ballet Alert! and Ballet Talk for Dancers year round by using this search box for your amazon.com purchases (adblockers may block display):